Chapter 02 of 5
The Scavenger's Dilemma
Hobbes introduces a second ship built from the discarded original planks.
- The Twist
Enter Thomas Hobbes
In the 17th century, philosopher Thomas Hobbes took the Greek paradox to a radical new level. He didn't just replace the wood; he saved the waste.
- The Scavenger
The Reassembly Plot
Imagine a scavenger follows Theseus, collecting every rotting plank discarded by the shipwrights. They store these pieces in a warehouse for years.
- The Construction
A Second Ship
Once the original ship is fully renovated, the scavenger rebuilds a ship using only the old, discarded wood. Now, two ships sit in the harbor.
17 more cards in this chapter
Could you answer this?
In Hobbes's version of the paradox, what defines the 'Scavenger's Ship' (Ship B)?
⛵ The Ship of Theseus: The Paradox of Identity
- 01The Docks of AthensExamine the foundational paradox of gradual replacement and persistence.
- 02The Scavenger's DilemmaHobbes introduces a second ship built from the discarded original planks.
- 03The Biological ShipApply the paradox to the human body and the constant cycle of cellular death.
- 04The Teletransporter ParadoxA deep dive into Parfit’s experiment on digital replication and destruction.
- 05The Narrative EgoSynthesizing the paradox into theories of psychological and legal identity.